The Middle East Channel
When Egyptian-Americans vote
Egyptian-Americans let out a collective sigh of relief this week. After months of governmental handwringing, the Egyptian High Elections Commission finally confirmed that Egyptians abroad will be able to exercise their right to vote in upcoming parliamentary and presidential elections. Egyptian expatriates were permitted to begin registering yesterday on the Commission’s website. Since the fall ...
Egyptian-Americans let out a collective sigh of relief this week. After months of governmental handwringing, the Egyptian High Elections Commission finally confirmed that Egyptians abroad will be able to exercise their right to vote in upcoming parliamentary and presidential elections. Egyptian expatriates were permitted to begin registering yesterday on the Commission’s website. Since the fall of Hosni Mubarak, Egyptian-Americans have struggled to find their place in the new Egypt. But their participation in Egypt’s first real elections will prove what they already knew — that they too are Egyptians and they too will help chart Egypt’s new course.
Like their fellow Egyptians in Tahrir Square, Egyptian-Americans rose up and demanded the fall of the regime on January 25. But unlike their compatriots in Tahrir, Egyptian-Americans also had to prove — to others but more importantly to themselves — that their demands were just as legitimate, that their voice was just as authentic.
On the one hand, the revolution caused a resurgence in pride in the homeland, propelling a once largely inactive and apolitical diaspora to seek out avenues of participation. According to Amin Mahmoud of the Alliance of Egyptian Americans, Hosni Mubarak had successfully "brainwashed" Egyptian-Americans to destroy their "ethic of political participation." But January 25 helped Egyptian-Americans to raise their heads high once more. Egyptian pride surged so strongly that noted political dissident Dr. Saad Eddin Ibrahim suggests it even "almost bordered on chauvinism."
On the other hand, the revolution exacerbated pre-existing insecurities over the authenticity of the community’s Egyptian identity. Many Egyptian-Americans who could not physically participate in Tahrir Square cannot help but feel a sense that their "Egyptianness" is now somehow lacking. As Dalia Mogahed of the Gallup Center for Muslim Studies observes, "I don’t know any Egyptians outside Egypt who didn’t feel an incredible sense that they were left out, that they had missed out, almost like a sense of loss."
When Asmaa, a young Egyptian-American from New York, heard Hosni Mubarak had resigned, she began to cry as pride intermingled with longing. She recalls, "I really wanted to be there. I wish I had been a part of it, but I really wasn’t. I did what I could here. I did my share here. But I still wish I had been there to be 100 percent a part of it."
This potent mix of pride and longing has spurred the Egyptian-American community into action. Instead of fixating on the inability to participate in Tahrir Square, Ibrahim Hussein of the Alliance of Egyptian Americans urged the community to build a "chapter of Tahrir Square" here in the United States. So they organized, protested, broadcasted, lobbied, and fundraised.
More than any other issue, Egyptian-Americans have fixated their demands on their right to vote. Just as Tahrir Square defined Egypt’s 18-day uprising, the outcome of the upcoming parliamentary and presidential elections will define post-revolutionary Egypt. Egyptian-Americans could accept that geography prevented their direct participation in the first seminal event. However, they will not accept the Egyptian government preventing their participation in the second. But more fundamentally, elections will now also define what it means to be Egyptian in a society in which citizens choose how they are governed and by whom. Nothing else would so definitively support the Egyptian-American claim of authentic Egyptian identity and voice than voting in Egypt’s elections.
This week’s announcement by the High Elections Commission thus represents a great victory for Egyptian-Americans, but several concerns remain. First, it is not clear how many Egyptian-Americans will actually get to vote. The High Elections Commission will allow Egyptians outside Egypt to register to vote from November 10 to November 19. With the first round of parliamentary elections scheduled for November 28, time is quite short to validate the registration process and work out any kinks. Moreover, many Egyptian-Americans do not possess an identification card, and only those who secured one before September 27 will be eligible to vote in the parliamentary elections. Poll stations will only be available at Egyptian embassies and consulates, so those Egyptian-Americans who do not live near one of these locations will either have to travel or forego their right to vote. Additionally, there is always the concern that votes cast will still not be counted honestly.
Second, beyond administrative obstacles, Egyptian-Americans also face a difficult political environment in Egypt. Since the revolution, Egypt has experienced a sharp increase in xenophobia, paranoia, and distrust of anything perceived as foreign. In this hostile environment, Egyptian-Americans can often struggle to find acceptance, especially with the underlying resentment that they did not suffer under Mubarak, as did others. Egyptian-Americans are even occasionally dismissed as khawaga, a colloquial term for foreigner.
Last month, Egyptian-Americans planned a conference in Washington, DC to host many of the major presidential candidates. These candidates faced a political backlash largely driven by paranoia of foreign conspiracy. Due to the fear that any attendees would be perceived as "American lackeys," only three candidates participated in the conference, none of which have any chance of winning. Yet this paranoia over foreign plots does not extend throughout Egyptian society, and the Egyptian revolutionaries have especially shown strong support for expatriate participation. At the conference, April 6 Youth Movement co-founder Ahmed Maher praised Egyptian-Americans for their role in building a new Egypt. Also, presidential candidate Bouthaina Kamel encouraged Egyptian-Americans to seize their fate in their revolution.
Third, beyond the fear of foreign conspiracy, there are concerns that expatriate voting will be susceptible to fraud. The judiciary branch typically monitors Egyptian elections, but there already too few judges to monitor all of the polling stations in Egypt at once. That is why parliamentary elections will have to be drawn out over several rounds. Having judges fly across the globe to monitor polling at embassies and consulates is simply impossible. Special exceptions will have to be made to allow foreign ministry officials to monitor international ballot boxes.
But the concern over fraud is likely overblown. American University of Cairo professor Samer Soliman contends in a recent Al-Ahram Online article that expat Egyptians are less susceptible to voter coercion than Egyptians at home. In fact, he suggests the "interim powers" have cynically raised such concerns because they actually fear Egyptians abroad will be able to vote freely.
Fourth, it is not clear how the Egyptian expatriate vote will affect the election results. Egyptian-Americans will likely vote more for liberal parties than the Egyptian population as a whole for a few reasons. As Khaled Elgindy of the Egyptian American Rule of Law Association observes, Egyptian-Americans are not completely representative of Egyptians generally because of their higher standard of living, level of education, and access to information. In addition, Coptic Christians enjoy a far stronger voice in the Egyptian-American community than they do in Egypt. And perhaps most importantly, Egyptian-Americans are more accustomed to and supportive of the liberal, free market American system.
Yet Egyptian-Americans represent only a fraction of the approximated eight million Egyptian expatriates who just gained access to the ballot box. Historically, the money and ideas flowing from Egyptians living in Gulf countries have had a tremendous effect in promoting a more conservative Egyptian society generally and Islamist groups particularly. They too possess the right to vote, and they too will exercise it. While it is not clear which political groups stand to gain the most from the expat vote as a whole, the recent Tunisian elections may prove instructive. The Islamist party Ennahda garnered approximately 40 percent of the Tunisian expat vote, far exceeding its nearest competitor.
Finally, while Egyptian-Americans have fixated on their right to vote, others are advising them to not forget the other ways they can help build a new Egypt. At the October conference, James Zogby of the Arab American Institute urged Egyptian-Americans to mobilize their economic resources stating, "Egypt doesn’t need your vote. It needs your investment and your ingenuity to help create jobs. You can’t feed people with a vote, but you can with a job." Meanwhile, Shadi Taha of the liberal al-Ghad party hopes Egyptian-Americans will become more active and effective within not just the Egyptian political system, but the American system as well. He encourages them "to become better organized, to take a stronger stand, to vote, to build relations with their representatives, to make their voices heard and to put the interests of the motherland at the top of their agenda."
Of course, Egyptian-Americans understand voting is not the only way to act upon their pride and longing for Egypt that has intensified since Mubarak’s fall. They understand their vote will differ from other Egyptian expat communities and from the Egyptian population as a whole. They understand concerns over fraud must be addressed. They understand they confront a political environment in Egypt that can show counterproductive hostility toward anything perceived as foreign. And they understand that the Egyptian government failed to deliver on a clear, well-conceived process to ensure all expats will be able to exercise their right to vote.
Despite all these concerns, voting in Egypt’s elections remains the best way for Egyptian-Americans to assert their Egyptian identity and to definitively prove the authenticity of their voice. As Dr. Samia Harris proclaimed at the October conference, "I’m not shy. I won’t apologize for it. Our role is to support all Egyptians in Egypt and empower Egyptians living here. Voting is a right, not a gift, and we are demanding our right."
Jason Stern is a master’s candidate at the Institute for Middle East Studies at George Washington University. He tweets and blogs under the handle @IbnLarry.
6Rex Tillerson Is Underrated 536 Shares