Everyone's talking about Egypt's presidential election. But what do the voters think?
- By Magdy SamaanEgyptian journalist Magdy Samaan works for the Daily Telegraph bureau in Cairo. He was a visiting fellow at the Atlantic Council's Rafik Hariri Institute for the Middle East and was a 2011 MENA Democracy Fellow at the World Affairs Institute.
The presidential election campaign in Egypt is under way. Thirteen candidates are competing for the job held for 30 years by Hosni Mubarak. The first round of the elections takes place on May 23 and 24. But so far no clear leaders have emerged.
Polling suggests that the main divide runs between Islamist candidates and those associated with the Mubarak regime. Among the former, the most likely contenders are Abdel Moneim Aboul Fotouh, a former member in the Guidance Bureau of the Muslim Brotherhood, and Mohamed Morsi, the current candidate of the Muslim Brotherhood. Those associated with the old regime include Amr Moussa, the ex-foreign minister and former secretary-general of the Arab League, and Ahmed Shafiq, Mubarak’s last prime minister. But the recent decision by the High Electoral Commission to exclude the previous front-runners on a variety of technical grounds has thrown the race into confusion.
We hear a lot about Egypt in the news these days, but we rarely have an opportunity to hear what Egyptians themselves think about what’s happening in their country. So we at Democracy Lab decided to ask Egyptians from all walks of life about their presidential preferences. On the eve of Egypt’s first-ever presidential debate, we present some of their responses — with a minimum of editorial intervention:
"The people are confused. If they elect a candidate from the former regime, does that mean that the country will go back to the way it was? But if they elect a candidate from the Islamists, they don’t know what course the country’s going to take, since the Islamists have no experience of actually being in power, and they have a tendency towards violence."
Saeed Abdul Aal, mid-40s, teacher from Izzbet El-Nakhel, north Cairo.
"Mubarak didn’t allow any other politicians to share the stage. He systematically eliminated anyone who was capable of competing with him. If you ban people from playing football in the neighborhood for a while, and then you allow them to play it again, their skills will be weak at first. Over time, the level of candidates will improve."
Mohammed Hassan Ali, 38, welder from Izzbet El-Nakhel.
Vote: Aboul Fotouh.
"Drivers spend nearly half a day waiting for a turn at the gas station. You work for a day and then you have to spend another day to get gas. If this country isn’t reformed, it will explode."
"Look at this vast desert we’ve got here. All that land is controlled by a small number of people who don’t use it. If one of the candidates announces that he will redistribute the unused land to the people, so that it can be used, I’ll vote for him."
"The Muslim Brotherhood is very influential in the countryside. People here expect their problems to be solved by God and the Brotherhood. For example, in religious festivals, Brotherhood Member of Parliament Abdul Aziz Khalaf buys clothes for the poor. He doesn’t charge people who can’t afford to pay for medicine from his pharmacy. No matter what else you hear about the Brotherhood, they’re people who aren’t going to change their minds."
Mahmoud Abu-Dahab, taxi driver from Assuit, 370 kilometers south of Cairo.
"In Upper Egypt, every group forms an opinion and the members of that group will follow it. The Copts will have a preferred candidate, and the Muslims will have another."
"Most Copts support Amr Moussa because he’s a secularist and won’t violate their freedom of religion. But I, like a lot of the other young Copts, support Hisham Al-Bastawisi, the candidate of [the secular leftist party] Al-Tagammu."
"Electing a new president, whatever his political orientation, does not mean that the regime will end. The regime, whose head was Mubarak, has lots of arms, such as the army, the police, and local municipalities. The demands of the revolution will continue."
Ehab Amir, 36, lawyer from the Coptic village of Izziyah, Assuit.
"I believe that the presidential election is part of a game between the SCAF and the Muslim Brotherhood. The Muslim Brotherhood got the parliament and the SCAF will get the presidency through one of the former regime candidates."
"I don’t trust Aboul Fotouh because he’s a former Muslim Brotherhood member. He says that he’s an independent, but I don’t believe him."
"I won’t vote for anyone who was associated with the former regime, or for anyone who’s associated with the current military regime that doesn’t respect human rights."
"I’ll vote for someone who can fight corruption so that we can build our country, so I’ll go with Abu Al-Izz Al-Hariri.
Marwa Rashed, 25, female graphic designer, Alexandria.
"The people are waiting for the election to end the unstable transitional period and bring a return to normal life. Even though the election is taking place under abnormal conditions, I still believe that electing a new president will be a step forward for stability, which we need."
"Coptic people are worried about an Islamic candidate winning because they think that will increase discrimination against them. I won’t be afraid as long the Islamists guarantee us equal rights."
Marian Nader, 19, female student at Ain Shmas University, from Mataryia, Cairo.
"Rich people want a candidate from the old regime, someone like Moussa or Shafiq, to return the country to the way it was. They want us to go on being their slaves and they want to go on being the masters. They want a president to maintain their interests and save them. But normal people are waiting for real programs that will get something done. People want the country to go in the right direction. The Egyptian people are too poor and too tired. They’ve spent their entire history being robbed. We want the new president to work for the people, not for special interests."
"I will decide when I see the programs, but I won’t vote for anyone who’s connected with the Mubarak regime."
Yasser Gamal, 38, government employee, Assuit.
"When people still respected the police, minibus drivers didn’t dare to do that [pointing at minibus drivers parking illegally in a public square]. I’ll nominate myself for president, and when I win, I’ll put all those drivers in prison. The only problem is that the prisons won’t have enough capacity, so I’ll have to build new ones."
Mahmoud Abdel Razek, 60s, taxi driver, Cairo.
"I think I’ll vote for Hisham Al-Bastawisi. He’s a fair judge who has a clean hand, but the Islamists will say that he’s secular and an infidel."
"The Islamists fooled us in the referendum and the parliamentary elections by using religion against the secular candidates, and they’ll fool the people again in the presidential election."
Hamada Abdullah, 29, taxi driver, Cairo.
"I’ll vote for Mohamed Morsi because we want a real Islamic state. Right now Egypt is an Islamic state in name but not in practice. ‘Islam is the solution’ was a slogan. Now we want to put it into practice."
Tanseem Al-Said, early 20s, female student in the Department of Islamic Studies at Mansoura University (and member of the Muslim Brotherhood).
"People still think that the next president will stay in power forever, but actually he’ll only be in power for four years, and then he’ll leave and someone else will replace him. We need a transition between the old regime and the new one. The new political parties can use this period to organize themselves."
Sami al-Abdullah, in his 50s, doctor, Cairo.
"I voted for the Brotherhood’s Freedom and Justice Party [in the last parliamentary elections], but I’m not going to vote for them again because of their [initial] decision not to run a candidate for the presidency. I was a supporter of the Brotherhood, but after they backed down I lost confidence in them — not only me but also most of my friends."
Ahmed Saeed, 23, student at Assuit University.
Vote: Aboul Fotouh.
"I supported [Salafi candidate] Hazem Salah Abu Ismail before he was disqualified [by the High Election Commission]. Now I’m going to boycott the election. I don’t want the Muslim Brotherhood to win the presidential election. We don’t want a single party to control everything. We don’t want a new National Democratic Party."
Mahmoud Ghareeb, 30, computer company owner in Assuit.
"We need someone to apply God’s holy law, not someone who is greedy for power. People in my neighborhood prefer the Islamic candidate. The candidates of the old regime, like Moussa and Shafiq, had the opportunity to do something in the past but they didn’t manage to get anything done. So I don’t believe that they’ll do anything now."
Amer Abu Alail, 48, sales director, Cairo.
"Omar Suleiman was my favorite candidate because he knows the ins and outs of the country. He can keep the current situation stable. Even if the situation is bad, the alternative is collapse. We’d rather live with a little water rather than brave the drought."
"Since Suleiman was disqualified, I support Shafiq. He’s better than the Islamists, the best of the worst."
Dahi Azer, 34, Copt, teacher from Assuit.
"I will not elect any secular candidate because he will be against Islam. We are afraid of the secularists, even if they’ve said that they will keep Article 2 [the constitutional clause that stipulates that sharia should be the basis of all legislation]. They may work against the religion from under the table. I don’t have any leanings toward a specific candidate. I lean towards an Islamic candidate who will apply sharia. That’s my first priority, and then I will look into who is better."
Waleed Wagdy, 30s, doctor, Assuit.
"We were deceived by the army. They realized that they can’t stand in front of the people’s protests, so they claimed that they were for the revolution even while they were working to control it."
"The election will be the last stage of the control process they’ve been putting in place in the last year and a half. Nothing has changed."
Sarah Mahmoud, 33, female doctor, Cairo.
"I wanted to vote for Hazem Salah Abu Ismail.. But when he was disqualified, Salafi leaders recommended that we vote for Aboul Fotouh. They know better than we do. I’ll vote as they say."
Mohammed Mosbah, early 20s, student at Mansoura University.
Vote: Aboul Fotouh.
"I won’t vote for a Brotherhood candidate. I don’t see any freedom or justice in what they do, only hearing and obeying the same policy of the blind majority. They obey the word of their own supreme guide more than the word of God."
Mahmoud Al-Mougi, 20, law student at Mansoura University.
Vote: Aboul Fotouh.