- By Thomas E. RicksThomas E. Ricks covered the U.S. military from 1991 to 2008 for the Wall Street Journal and then the Washington Post. He can be reached at email@example.com.
By Adam Johnson
Best Defense guest columnist
I agree with the notion that American culture tends to adore the elite Special Operations Forces (SOF) of our day.
After being commissioned in the U.S. Army, I was initially assigned to the 82nd Airborne Division at Fort Bragg. One thing I noticed upon my arrival, as my platoon sergeant pointed out, was that none of the soldiers in our infantry platoon enlisted into the U.S. Army to become 82nd Airborne Paratroopers — all aspired to become Army Rangers, Green Berets, etc., but were unsuccessful in those endeavors or transferred from other units.
Although joining a specially selected and well-trained unit is a noble venture, this trend speaks volumes about the desires of the current generation, my generation. I vividly recall my platoon sergeant describing a time when young Americans enlisted to become paratroopers because the maroon beret was considered elite. Maybe that is the case now, but during my time at Fort Bragg, enlisting to become a paratrooper seemed to be the next best thing due to an immense desire to work for a specialty unit “across the street.”
“Be all that you can be” typically meant joining the ranks of the conventional military in the 1980s and 90s. Both times and culture have changed since then, and this cultural shift is indicative of the age that we live in. So what influenced this change? I’d point toward the media.
When was the last time that Hollywood produced a film about a regular military unit?… chirp, chirp … It’s been a while. In fact, the only film that I can recall is Band of Brothers, and its first episode premiered prior to 9/11. Sure, there were other war and military films released over the last two decades, but they didn’t receive nearly the appeal as those featuring SOF units did. From Lone Survivor (Navy Seals), The Monuments Men (special soldiers selected to rescue art), Zero Dark Thirty (Navy Seals), 300: Rise of an Empire (Spartans), and on and on, recent war movies tend to focus on elite units. Quite frankly, Americans perceive them as more sexy.
The media has also been privy to increased levels of questionably classified information that has intentionally or unintentionally placed SOF units in the limelight. For instance, I recall the shock when President Obama announced that Navy Seals conducted the raid that killed Osama bin Laden. The shock factor not only resulted from the results of the raid, but also from highlighting the unit that conducted it. Again, an appeal toward a special operations unit.
All of the media coverage, movies, and attention propagate the glamour of special operations units and have, in part, influenced this change in heart. However, the simple fact remains: Not everyone in the military can be special.
Adam C. Johnson is a former military officer and graduate of West Point. He currently works at a think tank in Washington, D.C.