That anarchy keeps coming. Any day now…..

My reaction to Robert D. Kaplan’s Foreign Policy cover story, "The Revenge of Geography," can be summed up in the following joke: Question:  Why will Robert Kaplan never do well at Guitar Hero? Answer:  Because you can only go so far playing just one note.  Kaplan has been saying the same thing for fifteen years ...

By , a professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.

My reaction to Robert D. Kaplan's Foreign Policy cover story, "The Revenge of Geography," can be summed up in the following joke:

Question:  Why will Robert Kaplan never do well at Guitar Hero?

Answer:  Because you can only go so far playing just one note. 

My reaction to Robert D. Kaplan’s Foreign Policy cover story, "The Revenge of Geography," can be summed up in the following joke:

Question:  Why will Robert Kaplan never do well at Guitar Hero?

Answer:  Because you can only go so far playing just one note. 

Kaplan has been saying the same thing for fifteen years now.  This paragraph from his FP essay encapsulates this point: 

The ability of states to control events will be diluted, in some cases destroyed. Artificial borders will crumble and become more fissiparous, leaving only rivers, deserts, mountains, and other enduring facts of geography. Indeed, the physical features of the landscape may be the only reliable guides left to understanding the shape of future conflict. Like rifts in the Earth’s crust that produce physical instability, there are areas in Eurasia that are more prone to conflict than others. These “shatter zones” threaten to implode, explode, or maintain a fragile equilibrium. And not surprisingly, they fall within that unstable inner core of Eurasia: the greater Middle East, the vast way station between the Mediterranean world and the Indian subcontinent that registers all the primary shifts in global power politics.

Look, this is a good and important note, as anyone paying attention to Pakistan recently would attest. But let me dust off something I wrote about one of Kaplan’s earlier books oh-so-many-years ago: 

Kaplan discovers that countries with corrupt governments, stagnant economies, and short histories of statehood are falling apart.  In other words, Kaplan looks only at failed states and concludes that all states are failing.  He believes these trends can be generalized to the rest of the world, yet his own descriptions [in The Coming Anarchy] contradict him.  In the countries where statehood has a longer tradition, such as Turkey, Iran, and Thailand, Kaplan finds a stronger state and a less fragmented populace.  This observation severs the contagion effect Kaplan wants to ascribe to events in West Africa and Central Asia. 

Kaplan believes in the power of geography to disrupt man-made institutions.  He’s right some of the time, and some of these cases are pretty important.  In general, however, the state — even supposedly weak states — have proven to be remarkably resilient institutions.   

Daniel W. Drezner is a professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, where he is the co-director of the Russia and Eurasia Program. Twitter: @dandrezner

More from Foreign Policy

A propaganda poster from the 1960s shows Chinese leader Mao Zedong.
A propaganda poster from the 1960s shows Chinese leader Mao Zedong.

Xi’s Great Leap Backward

Beijing is running out of recipes for its looming jobs crisis—and reviving Mao-era policies.

A textile worker at the Maxport factory in Hanoi on Sept. 21, 2021.
A textile worker at the Maxport factory in Hanoi on Sept. 21, 2021.

Companies Are Fleeing China for Friendlier Shores

“Friendshoring” is the new trend as geopolitics bites.

German children stand atop building rubble in Berlin in 1948.
German children stand atop building rubble in Berlin in 1948.

Why Superpower Crises Are a Good Thing

A new era of tensions will focus minds and break logjams, as Cold War history shows.

Vacationers sit on a beach in Greece.
Vacationers sit on a beach in Greece.

The Mediterranean as We Know It Is Vanishing

From Saint-Tropez to Amalfi, the region’s most attractive tourist destinations are also its most vulnerable.