Allegations of CIA-backed torture in Palestine

A story in the Guardian yesterday about alleged CIA co-operation with Palestinian security forces involved in torture has exploded across the Arab media today.  There isn’t all that much new in the story, since such allegations have been widely circulating for years and have been investigated by a wide range of human rights organizations.  But ...

A story in the Guardian yesterday about alleged CIA co-operation with Palestinian security forces involved in torture has exploded across the Arab media today.  There isn't all that much new in the story, since such allegations have been widely circulating for years and have been investigated by a wide range of human rights organizations.  But the way the story is playing out now is all too familiar.  It will likely further discredit the Palestinian Authority and Salam Fayyad's government, give greater traction to the widespread complaints about the role of U.S. trained security forces, and strengthen the Hamas arguments within the Palestinian public. 

A story in the Guardian yesterday about alleged CIA co-operation with Palestinian security forces involved in torture has exploded across the Arab media today.  There isn’t all that much new in the story, since such allegations have been widely circulating for years and have been investigated by a wide range of human rights organizations.  But the way the story is playing out now is all too familiar.  It will likely further discredit the Palestinian Authority and Salam Fayyad’s government, give greater traction to the widespread complaints about the role of U.S. trained security forces, and strengthen the Hamas arguments within the Palestinian public. 

The Guardian story carefully distinguishes between the intelligence agencies working directly with their Palestinian counterparts on the one hand, and the security forces being trained by General Keith Dayton on the other.  This part rings true, given the way U.S. security efforts are organized over there.   But at the political level it probably doesn’t matter.  As Brian Katulis and I warned some six months ago, "Palestinians will not likely distinguish between different chains of command" when faced with such abuses.  Dayton and Fayyad’s efforts could be badly undermined even if the alleged abuses were done by other agencies beyond their control.   Such discontent is of course magnified a thousand-fold by the general atmosphere of political crisis after the Goldstone report fiasco, the cancelation of Palestinian elections and failure to get a national unity agreement, and the frustration over a settlement freeze.

This doesn’t come out of nowhere, of course.   Complaints about the U.S. trained Palestinian security forces have been swirling for a long time now (remember David Rose’s Vanity Fair story about Gaza? or the controversy over Dayton’s speech to the Washington Institute?).  Such abuses have always been one of the great dangers of a security-first approach which fails to develop a commensurate institutional foundation for the rule of law (see Yezid Sayigh’s excellent recent brief on security sector reform in Palestine and elsewhere for more).  They may help in the short term to establish "security" but can have highly negative long-term effects in terms of the legitimacy of the emerging political institutions and the imbalance between the security and civil sectors.  And in the absence of any political horizon for negotiations towards a Palestinian state, even the security efforts will likely become unsustainable.    

There’s also a strategic communications angle here. The story is spreading virally through new media and is all over the Arab mass media.  Thus far I’ve seen little effective American engagement with this potentially devastating story, other than a routine denial by the CIA spokesman.   That denial has been included in most of the stories I’ve seen (including al-Jazeera’s and several Palestinian papers), but doesn’t seem likely to make a dent in the circulation of the story. Most people I’ve heard from just assume it’s true.   This is one of those issues which needs to be confronted head on:  with a communications strategy and with real policy adjustments to make that strategy credible and true. 

Marc Lynch is associate professor of political science and international affairs at George Washington University, where he is the director of the Institute for Middle East Studies and of the Project on Middle East Political Science. He is also a non-resident senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security. He is the author of The Arab Uprising (March 2012, PublicAffairs).

He publishes frequently on the politics of the Middle East, with a particular focus on the Arab media and information technology, Iraq, Jordan, Egypt, and Islamist movements. Twitter: @abuaardvark

More from Foreign Policy

A photo illustration shows Chinese President Xi Jinping and U.S. President Joe Biden posing on pedestals atop the bipolar world order, with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, and Russian President Vladamir Putin standing below on a gridded floor.
A photo illustration shows Chinese President Xi Jinping and U.S. President Joe Biden posing on pedestals atop the bipolar world order, with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, and Russian President Vladamir Putin standing below on a gridded floor.

No, the World Is Not Multipolar

The idea of emerging power centers is popular but wrong—and could lead to serious policy mistakes.

A view from the cockpit shows backlit control panels and two pilots inside a KC-130J aerial refueler en route from Williamtown to Darwin as the sun sets on the horizon.
A view from the cockpit shows backlit control panels and two pilots inside a KC-130J aerial refueler en route from Williamtown to Darwin as the sun sets on the horizon.

America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want

Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.

The Chinese flag is raised during the opening ceremony of the Beijing Winter Olympics at Beijing National Stadium on Feb. 4, 2022.
The Chinese flag is raised during the opening ceremony of the Beijing Winter Olympics at Beijing National Stadium on Feb. 4, 2022.

America Can’t Stop China’s Rise

And it should stop trying.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky looks on prior a meeting with European Union leaders in Mariinsky Palace, in Kyiv, on June 16, 2022.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky looks on prior a meeting with European Union leaders in Mariinsky Palace, in Kyiv, on June 16, 2022.

The Morality of Ukraine’s War Is Very Murky

The ethical calculations are less clear than you might think.