Did Elena Kagan really pal around with ‘the worst judge on the planet’?

I think some of the concerns about Elena Kagan’s "blank slate" judicial record are understandable, but if this is the best line of attack Senate Republicans have against her, I don’t think she has a whole lot to worry about:  [Aharon] Barak, the retired president of the Supreme Court of Israel, has advocated an expansive ...

By , a former associate editor at Foreign Policy.
567561_barak_02.jpg
567561_barak_02.jpg
Jerusalem, Israel: 05/19/2004: Prime Minister Ariel Sharon at a Jerusalem Day ceremony at Ammunition Hill, commemorating those who fell during battle. (On right of Sharon is President Katsav. On Left of Sharon is Head of Supreme Court Aharon Barak.) ©David Blumenfeld/Newsweek Pool

I think some of the concerns about Elena Kagan's "blank slate" judicial record are understandable, but if this is the best line of attack Senate Republicans have against her, I don't think she has a whole lot to worry about: 

I think some of the concerns about Elena Kagan’s "blank slate" judicial record are understandable, but if this is the best line of attack Senate Republicans have against her, I don’t think she has a whole lot to worry about: 

[Aharon] Barak, the retired president of the Supreme Court of Israel, has advocated an expansive role for the judiciary in his home country. But in this country, he has emerged over the past few days as a kind of liberal judicial villain for Republicans and conservatives, who are trying to turn Ms. Kagan’s praise for him against her.

In 2006, while dean of Harvard Law School, Ms. Kagan introduced Judge Barak during an award ceremony as “my judicial hero.” She added, “He is the judge or justice in my lifetime whom, I think, best represents and has best advanced the values of democracy and human rights, of the rule of law and of justice.”[…]

Senator Jeff Sessions of Alabama, the top Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, on Thursday called Ms. Kagan’s introduction “very troubling” and suggested it “might provide real insight into her approach to the law.”

On Wednesday, Judge Robert Bork, whose own Supreme Court nomination in 1987 resulted in a Senate vote against confirmation, said Judge Barak “may be the worst judge on the planet, the most activist,” and argued that Ms. Kagan’s admiration for him is “disqualifying in and of itself.”

First of all, Barak advocates an expansive role for the judiciary in a country without a written constitution, so his views aren’t really analogous to the U.S. court system. And noted judicial activist Antonin Scalia has also praised him.

Secondly, can Robert Bork really believe that Barak is the "worst judge on the planet"? That would mean that Iran’s "judge of death," Abolghasem Salavat is a superior jurist to the former chief justice of the Israeli Supreme Court. I’d love to hear what the good folks at AIPAC have to say about that one.  

Joshua Keating was an associate editor at Foreign Policy. Twitter: @joshuakeating

More from Foreign Policy

A photo illustration shows Chinese President Xi Jinping and U.S. President Joe Biden posing on pedestals atop the bipolar world order, with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, and Russian President Vladamir Putin standing below on a gridded floor.
A photo illustration shows Chinese President Xi Jinping and U.S. President Joe Biden posing on pedestals atop the bipolar world order, with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, and Russian President Vladamir Putin standing below on a gridded floor.

No, the World Is Not Multipolar

The idea of emerging power centers is popular but wrong—and could lead to serious policy mistakes.

A view from the cockpit shows backlit control panels and two pilots inside a KC-130J aerial refueler en route from Williamtown to Darwin as the sun sets on the horizon.
A view from the cockpit shows backlit control panels and two pilots inside a KC-130J aerial refueler en route from Williamtown to Darwin as the sun sets on the horizon.

America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want

Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.

The Chinese flag is raised during the opening ceremony of the Beijing Winter Olympics at Beijing National Stadium on Feb. 4, 2022.
The Chinese flag is raised during the opening ceremony of the Beijing Winter Olympics at Beijing National Stadium on Feb. 4, 2022.

America Can’t Stop China’s Rise

And it should stop trying.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky looks on prior a meeting with European Union leaders in Mariinsky Palace, in Kyiv, on June 16, 2022.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky looks on prior a meeting with European Union leaders in Mariinsky Palace, in Kyiv, on June 16, 2022.

The Morality of Ukraine’s War Is Very Murky

The ethical calculations are less clear than you might think.