Civilian strategists often think they understand the use of force better than their generals do. Here are 10 cockamamie military schemes that thankfully never came to pass.
U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates once observed, “I have seen a lot of civilians make a lot of proposals for a lot of silly military actions.” In response to foreign-policy problems that resist easy solutions, the quick allure of military force is the civilian’s siren song. Many proposals — while informal or semiserious — are preposterous and overlook even a basic understanding of political objectives, military strategy, geography, and logistics. Here are the top 10 most ridiculous military options offered up by U.S. government officials or civilian commentators over the last few decades. Thankfully, these would-be civilian follies, based on unrealistic and often dangerous notions of what military power can achieve, were quashed before they left the drawing board.
John Moore/Getty Images
What: Acheson’s armed division on the autobahn
Target: Soviet provocation in Eastern Europe
In 1961, with tension high between the United States and the Soviet Union over Berlin, U.S. President John F. Kennedy asked former Secretary of State Dean Acheson to launch a systematic review of U.S. policy toward Germany. To signal America’s strong commitment to defending West Berlin, Acheson’s suggestion for dealing with the Berlin crisis was to send “an armored division, with another division in reserve” up the autobahn through East Germany and into West Berlin. Acheson admitted, “There is… a substantial possibility that war might result.” Kennedy wisely opted instead to bolster military readiness but avoid an outright provocation of the Soviet Union.
What: Gates’s air war in Central America
Target: Sandinista military buildup
In 1984, Robert Gates, then the deputy director of intelligence, offered a “straight talk” memo to his boss, CIA Director William J. Casey, that endorsed supporting the Contra rebels in Nicaragua with a “comprehensive campaign openly aimed at bringing down the [Sandinista] regime.” Among the “politically most difficult” measures Gates proposed were “the use of air strikes to destroy a considerable portion of Nicaragua’s military buildup.”
RODRIGO ARANGUA/AFP/Getty Images
What: Reagan administration’s Operation Rose
Target: Muammar al-Qaddafi
In 1985, officials in the Reagan administration’s National Security Council developed Operation Rose, which envisioned a joint U.S.-Egyptian land and air military campaign that would sweep into Libya to remove Muammar al-Qaddafi from power. The Pentagon considered the notion ludicrous, but dutifully developed plans that showed that Operation Rose would require six divisions and 90,000 U.S. soldiers. Needless to say, it didn’t happen.
MARWAN NAAMANI/AFP/Getty Images
What: Bill Clinton’s black ninjas
Target: Osama bin Laden
In 1999 or 2000, after the failed attempt to kill Osama bin Laden with some 80 cruise missiles launched into the al Qaeda camp in Khost, Afghanistan, a frustrated President Bill Clinton thought that somehow the United States could “scare the shit out of al Qaeda if suddenly a bunch of black ninjas rappelled out of helicopters into the middle of their camp,” according to the 9/11 Commission.
TOSHIFUMI KITAMURA/AFP/Getty Images
What: Mining the Iraq-Iran border
Target: Iranian arms in Iraq
In 2005, columnist Melik Kaylan, claiming that most foot soldiers and resources supplying the Iraqi Sunni insurgency came from outside the country, proposed “an effective method of interdiction… the laying of minefields” along the entirety of Iraq’s borders — some 2,250 miles.
ESSAM AL-SUDANI/AFP/Getty Images
What: Pat Robertson’s Red Scare
Target: Hugo Chávez
In 2005, to prevent Venezuela from becoming “a launching pad for communist infiltration and Muslim extremism all over the continent,” conservative pastor Pat Robertson declared “that we really ought to go ahead and [assassinate]” Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez because “it’s a whole lot cheaper than starting a war.”
ANDREW ALVAREZ/AFP/Getty Images
What: Bombs over Pyongyang
Target: North Korea’s ballistic missiles
In 2006, William Perry and Ashton Carter, secretary and assistant secretary of defense in Bill Clinton’s administration, respectively, proposed bombing North Korea’s Taepodong long-range ballistic missile while it was poised to launch. In a nod to bipartisanship, in 2009 Philip Zelikow, a State Department official during George W. Bush’s administration, also endorsed bombing North Korean missiles.
Chung Sung-Jun/Getty Images
What: The invasion of Zimbabwe
Target: Robert Mugabe
In 2008, Washington Post columnist Richard Cohen called for using an unmanned Predator drone to kill Robert Mugabe — a scheme one-upped by former diplomat and human rights advocate John Prendergast, who suggested a “messy in the short run” multinational conventional military invasion to oust the Zimbabwean president.
DESMOND KWANDE/AFP/Getty Images
What: Clip Khartoum’s wings
Target: Omar Hassan al-Bashir
Over the past few years, New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof has proposed several military operations for dealing with Sudanese President Omar Hassan al-Bashir’s regime in Khartoum in retaliation for its systematic human rights abuses against Sudanese populations. In 2006, Kristof recommended that the United States “enforce a no-fly zone in Darfur by using the nearby Chadian air base in Abeché”; called in 2008 for the United States to “warn Sudan that if it provokes a war with the South… we will destroy its air force”; and this year urged U.S. President Barack Obama to warn Bashir that “if he initiates genocide, his oil pipeline will be destroyed and he will not be exporting any oil.”
SALAH OMAR/AFP/Getty Images
What: March to the Sea (of Waziristan)
Target: Osama bin Laden
This October, Jack Devine, a 32-year veteran of the CIA, advised Obama to “forget about nation-building in Afghanistan and, like [Gen. William Tecumseh] Sherman marching across Georgia during the Civil War, march our army across eastern Afghanistan, pressing forward even into Pakistan’s Northwest Frontier, and continue the march until we capture [Osama bin Laden].” Devine hoped to avoid the invasion because once Pakistan knew of the U.S. plans, “it’s a pretty good bet that we would have bin Laden’s head on a platter.” Uh-huh.
John Moore/Getty Images
Micah Zenko is the co-author of Clear and Present Safety: The World Has Never Been Better and Why That Matters to Americans. Twitter: @MicahZenko
More from Foreign Policy
No, the World Is Not Multipolar
The idea of emerging power centers is popular but wrong—and could lead to serious policy mistakes.
America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want
Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.
America Can’t Stop China’s Rise
And it should stop trying.
The Morality of Ukraine’s War Is Very Murky
The ethical calculations are less clear than you might think.