West Point (III): I love the USMA, but I’d still like to give it a makeover
Here’s a guest column that follows on Bob Bateman’s column on Friday, from an old friend I know from Forts Benning and Bragg. By Col. Johnny Brooks (U.S. Army, ret.) Best Defense guest columnist As I work quite a lot with USMC lieutenants and captains on a daily basis, I can tell you, there are ...
Here's a guest column that follows on Bob Bateman's column on Friday, from an old friend I know from Forts Benning and Bragg.
Here’s a guest column that follows on Bob Bateman’s column on Friday, from an old friend I know from Forts Benning and Bragg.
By Col. Johnny Brooks (U.S. Army, ret.)
Best Defense guest columnist
As I work quite a lot with USMC lieutenants and captains on a daily basis, I can tell you, there are good ones and bad ones, same as in any Army. Anyone who wants to proclaim the USMC officer corps as the creme doesn’t have a good perspective. I don’t think there is any difference in the competence level of USMC lieutenants/captains and Army lieutenants/captains.
As for military training at West Point, it is in need of changes. I have been torn for years about what West Point is doing. I sometimes think all cadets at West Point should come from the ranks. I sometimes think that West Point should be a non-degree producing school like Sandhurst. I sometimes think that West Point should worry more about producing officers than about producing Rhodes, Hertz or MacArthur Scholars. But each time I come back to the fact that ours is a different society. If the service academies did not offer a degree, who would go? A degree was not essential in the British Army til lately, while it has been in ours for 50 years. Got to tell you when I was a company commander in the British Army, I had to replace two platoon leaders. Having commanded two companies in the U.S. Army I never had a lieutenant so bad I had to relieve him. Which system is better?
I once suggested to the leadership of West Point that they should require all graduates to be fluent in a foreign language. I was summarily executed and informed that four years of foreign language does not fit into the engineering curriculum. I have recommended that they reduce the academic admissions standards in order to get a more rounded cadet, one who more than likely would stay in the Army for a longer time and make a career of it. I was summarily executed because you don’t win Rhodes Scholarships that way. Numerous other points of discussion have also been canned.
You only need a couple of Dave Petraeus’s in a decade, but you need a lot of Johnny Brooks to have an Army. Still, they want everyone to have the potential to be a Petraeus. So, they go for the gusto and it is an academic institution — or, as my son said, "An Ivy League School with uniforms." Abizaid hated that when I told him that is what cadets referred to WP as. And, as for cadets complaining about inspections; there is nothing keeping them there but a free education. They can quit any time they want. No guards are on the inside of the gates keeping cadets in.
I’m getting too emotional. I love the place, but believe you me, West Point struggles with combatting the American societal norms in order to produce a reasonable product.
More from Foreign Policy
A New Multilateralism
How the United States can rejuvenate the global institutions it created.
America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want
Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.
The Endless Frustration of Chinese Diplomacy
Beijing’s representatives are always scared they could be the next to vanish.
The End of America’s Middle East
The region’s four major countries have all forfeited Washington’s trust.