Fixing the Army (IV): Trim support branch generals, civilianize non-deployers — and start mowing your own damn lawn
By "Petronius Arbiter" Best Defense department of Army affairs Support IMCOM should be completely civilianized as it is totally non-deployable. 6 General officers in IMCOM is somewhat disturbing. IMCOM GO in Korea is particularly disturbing with 22 installations and 17k Army personnel in all of 8th Army. Establish one Army Warfighting Lab under direction of ...
By "Petronius Arbiter"
Best Defense department of Army affairs
Support
IMCOM should be completely civilianized as it is totally non-deployable. 6 General officers in IMCOM is somewhat disturbing. IMCOM GO in Korea is particularly disturbing with 22 installations and 17k Army personnel in all of 8th Army. Establish one Army Warfighting Lab under direction of TRADOC. Resource with a BG and appropriate fiscal and personnel resources to have an impact. Eliminate TRADOC battle labs, use resources saved to improve Soldier equipping and training. Yep, copy from USMC. It works for them only because it is a point of emphasis by Commandant, USMC. Yes, this is small growth in GO corps, but would well serve the Army and the ability to focus on the CSA needs and priorities. U.S. Army MEDCOM is a huge and geographically dispersed command. Maintain The Surgeon General as a LTG. But, there are 19 Medical Department (MC,MS, MSC, AN, VC) GOs on the rolls. If my memory is correct there were 6 at the height of the Cold War. Not to pick on the Veterinary Corps, but are there enough Vets in the Army to warrant a GO? Or is it all about hope? Reduce SJA GO-level positions. Return TJAG of Army to MG. There are 7 JAG GOs serving now. At the height of the Cold War there were 2 on active duty. There are no JAG commands, so why so many GOs? The TJAG makes policy and personnel management decisions, so why so many senior officers? Is this one of those decisions just to give "hope" to those to keep them in the service? Reduce Chaplain GOs back to normal of 2. There are 3 GO Chaplains now. Why does USAREUR have a GO Chaplain with only 4 brigades? There probably are not 40 Chaplains in all USAREUR. This is only a small issue in the grander scale but an indication of the real problem, too much hierarchy. Every GO has a staff and a staff is adding to a smaller "tooth to tail" ratio. Personnel living on post maintain their own quarters area. Specifically, post support contracts should not resource grass cutting. Save some money here. GOs provided for accordingly and they should be. Ensure that quarters areas are again divided by rank; enlisted, NCO, SGM/CSM, junior officer, field grade officer, senior officer and GO. Do not mix senior NCO and field grade officers. They are not the same. An NCO is an NCO and a field grade is a field grade. The Army is not an egalitarian society and can't function as one. Familiarity does breed contempt. This issue varies from post to post.
By "Petronius Arbiter"
Best Defense department of Army affairs
Support
- IMCOM should be completely civilianized as it is totally non-deployable. 6 General officers in IMCOM is somewhat disturbing. IMCOM GO in Korea is particularly disturbing with 22 installations and 17k Army personnel in all of 8th Army.
- Establish one Army Warfighting Lab under direction of TRADOC. Resource with a BG and appropriate fiscal and personnel resources to have an impact. Eliminate TRADOC battle labs, use resources saved to improve Soldier equipping and training. Yep, copy from USMC. It works for them only because it is a point of emphasis by Commandant, USMC. Yes, this is small growth in GO corps, but would well serve the Army and the ability to focus on the CSA needs and priorities.
- U.S. Army MEDCOM is a huge and geographically dispersed command. Maintain The Surgeon General as a LTG. But, there are 19 Medical Department (MC,MS, MSC, AN, VC) GOs on the rolls. If my memory is correct there were 6 at the height of the Cold War. Not to pick on the Veterinary Corps, but are there enough Vets in the Army to warrant a GO? Or is it all about hope?
- Reduce SJA GO-level positions. Return TJAG of Army to MG. There are 7 JAG GOs serving now. At the height of the Cold War there were 2 on active duty. There are no JAG commands, so why so many GOs? The TJAG makes policy and personnel management decisions, so why so many senior officers? Is this one of those decisions just to give "hope" to those to keep them in the service?
- Reduce Chaplain GOs back to normal of 2. There are 3 GO Chaplains now. Why does USAREUR have a GO Chaplain with only 4 brigades? There probably are not 40 Chaplains in all USAREUR. This is only a small issue in the grander scale but an indication of the real problem, too much hierarchy. Every GO has a staff and a staff is adding to a smaller "tooth to tail" ratio.
- Personnel living on post maintain their own quarters area. Specifically, post support contracts should not resource grass cutting. Save some money here. GOs provided for accordingly and they should be.
- Ensure that quarters areas are again divided by rank; enlisted, NCO, SGM/CSM, junior officer, field grade officer, senior officer and GO. Do not mix senior NCO and field grade officers. They are not the same. An NCO is an NCO and a field grade is a field grade. The Army is not an egalitarian society and can’t function as one. Familiarity does breed contempt. This issue varies from post to post.
More from Foreign Policy
Lessons for the Next War
Twelve experts weigh in on how to prevent, deter, and—if necessary—fight the next conflict.
It’s High Time to Prepare for Russia’s Collapse
Not planning for the possibility of disintegration betrays a dangerous lack of imagination.
Turkey Is Sending Cold War-Era Cluster Bombs to Ukraine
The artillery-fired cluster munitions could be lethal to Russian troops—and Ukrainian civilians.
Congrats, You’re a Member of Congress. Now Listen Up.
Some brief foreign-policy advice for the newest members of the U.S. legislature.
Sign up for Morning Brief
Foreign Policy’s flagship daily newsletter with what’s coming up around the world today. Delivered weekdays.
By submitting your email, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive email correspondence from us. You may opt out at any time.
