On watching the New Zealand Army mourn: Maybe we should do the same
By Stacy Bare Best Defense rugby correspondent I wonder if there is not something deeply cathartic about the infantry unit performing the Haka, an ancient ritual designed to intimidate opponents, while also honoring them. In a few moments, the unit is able to express incredible, unified emotion, and sadness, while at the same time letting ...
By Stacy Bare
By Stacy Bare
Best Defense rugby correspondent
I wonder if there is not something deeply cathartic about the infantry unit performing the Haka, an ancient ritual designed to intimidate opponents, while also honoring them. In a few moments, the unit is able to express incredible, unified emotion, and sadness, while at the same time letting death know it will not break their unit’s camaraderie.
There is a respect shown to death itself here, a worthy opponent in its own right that accompanies the warrior regardless of the battlefield. Does the warrior culture of the Ma’ori people, seeped so thoroughly through the NZ Army, allow for greater resilience in the modern day soldiers? The first time I watched it I had tears streaming down my eyes and imagined myself and my old units performing the Haka for a dozen or so fallen comrades.
As a former rugby player I can relate to the strength and power of the ritual. When we had a large number of Fijians, Kiwis, and Samoans on the team we did a similar dance before games. Most of the Islanders were warriors and soldiers themselves. We do not have this kind of coming home in America, this reinforcement, even in death, of the inherent strength of our warriors. Are we overly sensitive, overly surprised that in war, maiming and death occur?
Then again, one wonders if the number of deaths of the NZ forces equated to ours, would this Haka happen every time there?
Still, I can’t help but think if when our brothers and sisters came home, if we allowed ourselves the opportunity to yell, to scream, and to shake our tongues at death, we wouldn’t be a far healthier society.
Stacy Bare served as a captain in the U.S. Army from 2000-2004 and again from 2006-2007. He served as the Counter Terrorism Team Chief in Sarajevo, Bosnia, in 2003-04 and as a Civil Affairs Team Chief in Baghdad, Iraq, from 2006-07. He is now the Director of Outdoor Programming for the Sierra Club.
More from Foreign Policy
No, the World Is Not Multipolar
The idea of emerging power centers is popular but wrong—and could lead to serious policy mistakes.
America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want
Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.
America Can’t Stop China’s Rise
And it should stop trying.
The Morality of Ukraine’s War Is Very Murky
The ethical calculations are less clear than you might think.