McCain goes all in: fight or retreat

Go all in or go home. An exasperated Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) offered that stunning new take on the war in Afghanistan on Thursday, saying the U.S. should either halt the drawdown from Afghanistan and leave 68,000 troops there to fight through 2014, or consider ending the war altogether.   The statement from McCain, ranking ...

By , a former staff writer at Foreign Policy.
Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call
Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call
Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call

Go all in or go home. An exasperated Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) offered that stunning new take on the war in Afghanistan on Thursday, saying the U.S. should either halt the drawdown from Afghanistan and leave 68,000 troops there to fight through 2014, or consider ending the war altogether.
 
The statement from McCain, ranking member of the Senate Armed Services Committee and leading Republican voice on the war, came as a criticism of President Obama’s stated plans to steadily reduce troop levels in Afghanistan. McCain has long questioned if the mission to build Afghan forces and hand over security to them by 2015 is possible with a concurrent troop pullout.
 
But it also was a publically delivered message to Obama’s presumed next Afghanistan war commander, Marine Corps Gen. Joseph Dunford, who appeared in his confirmation hearing.
 
“If we can’t accomplish the mission, I’m not sure why we should stay,” McCain said, offering a view of the war virtually unheard during the presidential campaign season that just ended.
 
“There’s three of us here, general, who have been going over there for the last 11 years.” McCain continued. “And we haven’t seen the progress that we had hoped would take place. And we do see quite often sentiment by the part of Afghans and their neighbors that the United States spends most of its time announcing withdrawals and dates for withdrawals rather than recipes for success. Some of us, as I say, we’ve been observing this for a long, long time, made many, many visits and many, many briefings, are deeply concerned.”
 
Dunford is nominated to succeed Gen. John Allen, whose nomination to take over NATO has been put on hold while a Defense Department investigation looks into tens of thousands of pages of emails the Pentagon said include “flirtatious” exchanges with a married woman in Florida.
 

Go all in or go home. An exasperated Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) offered that stunning new take on the war in Afghanistan on Thursday, saying the U.S. should either halt the drawdown from Afghanistan and leave 68,000 troops there to fight through 2014, or consider ending the war altogether.
 
The statement from McCain, ranking member of the Senate Armed Services Committee and leading Republican voice on the war, came as a criticism of President Obama’s stated plans to steadily reduce troop levels in Afghanistan. McCain has long questioned if the mission to build Afghan forces and hand over security to them by 2015 is possible with a concurrent troop pullout.
 
But it also was a publically delivered message to Obama’s presumed next Afghanistan war commander, Marine Corps Gen. Joseph Dunford, who appeared in his confirmation hearing.
 
“If we can’t accomplish the mission, I’m not sure why we should stay,” McCain said, offering a view of the war virtually unheard during the presidential campaign season that just ended.
 
“There’s three of us here, general, who have been going over there for the last 11 years.” McCain continued. “And we haven’t seen the progress that we had hoped would take place. And we do see quite often sentiment by the part of Afghans and their neighbors that the United States spends most of its time announcing withdrawals and dates for withdrawals rather than recipes for success. Some of us, as I say, we’ve been observing this for a long, long time, made many, many visits and many, many briefings, are deeply concerned.”
 
Dunford is nominated to succeed Gen. John Allen, whose nomination to take over NATO has been put on hold while a Defense Department investigation looks into tens of thousands of pages of emails the Pentagon said include “flirtatious” exchanges with a married woman in Florida.
 

Kevin Baron is a former staff writer at Foreign Policy. Twitter: @FPBaron

More from Foreign Policy

Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger prepares to testify before the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee.
Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger prepares to testify before the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

Was Henry Kissinger Really a Realist?

America’s most famous 20th century statesman wasn’t exactly what he claimed to be.

The leader of the Palestinian Hamas movement, Ismail Haniyeh, shakes hands with Iranian Chief of Staff for the Armed Forces Mohammad Bagheri and the commander of Iran's Revolutionary Guard force, General Hossein Salami, during the swearing in ceremony for Iran's new president at the parliament in the Islamic republic's capital Tehran on August 5, 2021.
The leader of the Palestinian Hamas movement, Ismail Haniyeh, shakes hands with Iranian Chief of Staff for the Armed Forces Mohammad Bagheri and the commander of Iran's Revolutionary Guard force, General Hossein Salami, during the swearing in ceremony for Iran's new president at the parliament in the Islamic republic's capital Tehran on August 5, 2021.

The 7 Reasons Iran Won’t Fight for Hamas

A close look at Tehran’s thinking about escalating the war in Gaza.

A globe with blocks and chunks missing from it sits atop the shoulders of a person looking into a dystopian horizon.
A globe with blocks and chunks missing from it sits atop the shoulders of a person looking into a dystopian horizon.

The Global Credibility Gap

No one power or group can uphold the international order anymore—and that means much more geopolitical uncertainty ahead.

Joaquin Phoenix (center) stars in the film "Napoleon."
Joaquin Phoenix (center) stars in the film "Napoleon."

What Ridley Scott’s ‘Napoleon’ Gets Wrong About War

The film’s ideas have poisoned military thinking for centuries.