Study: Legalizing prostitution increases human trafficking
Despite the common view of the problem, not all, perhaps not even most, human trafficking across the world is related to prostituion. But sex trafficking is a significant enough factor — particularly in the United States — that it’s worth considering whether legalizing and regulating prostitution might be a way of reducing cross-border trafficking. A ...
Despite the common view of the problem, not all, perhaps not even most, human trafficking across the world is related to prostituion. But sex trafficking is a significant enough factor -- particularly in the United States -- that it's worth considering whether legalizing and regulating prostitution might be a way of reducing cross-border trafficking.
A paper recently published in World Development by economists Seo-young Cho, Axel Dreher, and Eric Neumeyer takes up this question, arguing that legalizing prostitution has two contradictory effects: "a substitution effect away from trafficking and a scale effect increasing trafficking."
In other words, in countries where prostitution is legal, more domestic sex workers will enter the market since they no longer fear arrest or imprisonment, reducing the demand for trafficked sex workers. On the other hand, legalization is also likely to increase the overall demand for prostitution, since johns no longer fear prosecution either. The question is, which effect is more significant?
Despite the common view of the problem, not all, perhaps not even most, human trafficking across the world is related to prostituion. But sex trafficking is a significant enough factor — particularly in the United States — that it’s worth considering whether legalizing and regulating prostitution might be a way of reducing cross-border trafficking.
A paper recently published in World Development by economists Seo-young Cho, Axel Dreher, and Eric Neumeyer takes up this question, arguing that legalizing prostitution has two contradictory effects: "a substitution effect away from trafficking and a scale effect increasing trafficking."
In other words, in countries where prostitution is legal, more domestic sex workers will enter the market since they no longer fear arrest or imprisonment, reducing the demand for trafficked sex workers. On the other hand, legalization is also likely to increase the overall demand for prostitution, since johns no longer fear prosecution either. The question is, which effect is more significant?
This paper suggests it’s the latter. Using trafficking data from 150 countries, the authors find that "countries where prostitution is legal experience a larger reported incidence of human trafficking inflows."
As an example, they discuss Germany, which legalized prostitution in 2002. The minimum estimate of sex trafficking victims in the country increased from 9,870 in 2001 to 11,080 in 2002, to 12,350 in 2003.
Does this mean legalizing prostitution is a bad idea? Well, not necessarily. The authors note that legalization could have other positive effects, such making it easier for prostitutes to seek legal or medical help and decreasing rates of abuse and sexually-transmitted disease. But it’s a trade-off both sides of the debate should take seriously.
Via Monkey Cage
Joshua Keating was an associate editor at Foreign Policy Twitter: @joshuakeating
More from Foreign Policy

Actually, the Russian Economy Is Imploding
Nine myths about the effects of sanctions and business retreats, debunked.

The Taliban Detained Me for Doing My Job. I Can Never Go Back.
FP’s columnist on a harrowing return to Kabul, almost one year after the United States left Afghanistan.

Russian Sanctions Are Working but Slowly
Moscow’s military capabilities are being ground down, piece by piece.

Ghana’s ‘Success’ Exposes the West’s Toxic Development Model
Standard theories of global progress continue to be largely limited to raw extraction.