Get Ready for an Olympics Filled With Potemkin Village Metaphors
If you’re a media outlet with any kind of a website, chances are you’ve run a story in the last 36 hours about the stream of complaints from journalists assembled in Sochi about the shoddy media accommodations. It’s all very meta. Doorknobs are falling off, hot water is lacking, an entire hotel lobby is missing, ...
If you're a media outlet with any kind of a website, chances are you've run a story in the last 36 hours about the stream of complaints from journalists assembled in Sochi about the shoddy media accommodations. It's all very meta.
If you’re a media outlet with any kind of a website, chances are you’ve run a story in the last 36 hours about the stream of complaints from journalists assembled in Sochi about the shoddy media accommodations. It’s all very meta.
Doorknobs are falling off, hot water is lacking, an entire hotel lobby is missing, and American news outlets can barely contain their glee in relaying the hellscape journalists have found themselves in. "Journalists at Sochi are live-tweeting their hilarious and gross hotel experiences," blared the Washington Post headline. "Bee-filled food, yellow water, stray dogs, strange toilets, and other adventures at the Sochi Olympics," USA Today cackled. The Hollywood Reporter even got in on the act: "Sochi: Hotel Horrors Haunt Olympic Journalists."
These headlines aren’t without irony: Western journalists have traveled to Russia in search of the country of their dreams, and, lo and behold, they have found it. This is the Russia of the Western imagination: Corrupt, hollow, and dysfunctional. Sadly, the initial reports out of Sochi indicate that Olympic Games are going to be covered in utterly predictable fashion: as a confirmation of everything terrible the West thinks about Russia. The toilets don’t have doors! The water can’t be consumed! The people are impossible!
The shoddy accommodations, in particular, are sure to feature heavily in every Sochi story you will read from now until the Olympics’ end. They play on an old notion of Russia in the Western imagination: a land filled with Potemkin villages. The comparison is appearing in the media, and it certainly won’t go away anytime soon. Is there some truth to the notion that Sochi was largely constructed as a vanity project — and, yes, a Potemkin village — to please Tsar Putin? Certainly. But the metaphor will be deployed with such laziness as to be meaningless. Here’s the takeaway from the Toronto Star’s piece comparing Sochi to a Potemkin village: "It feels like a place that is desperate to impress but just can’t quite get the details right, no matter that $51 billion was somehow spread around to make it happen."
The notion that Sochi is "desperate to impress" is particularly hilarious. Isn’t that the sole purpose of hosting the Olympics? The 2008 Beijing Olympics were heralded as China’s arrival on the world stage. And at the conclusion of the 2012 London Olympics, none other than David Cameron declared to his countrymen that "we showed the world what we’re made of, we reminded ourselves what we can do." Was he called "desperate to impress" for that, well, rather desperate statement? Of course not.
It isn’t that these tropes about Russia don’t contain a shred of truth – the country certainly is corrupt, cold, and very fond of vodka – rather, it’s that Western coverage of Russia all too often presents the sad realities behind these stereotypes without any kind of nuance or imagination. Among the more recurring features of pre-Sochi coverage has been the obsession with a pair of side-by-side toilets inside the same stall. The toilets have become something of an Internet sensation. Journalists keep discovering them all over the resort and have been furiously tweeting images of them. They have now become something of a (strained) metaphor for the games. For what kind of management could fail to install a divider between toilets?
Put another way, what kind of journalist is sufficiently lazy to make a pair of toilets the central metaphor of his Sochi coverage?
Putin often complains that Russia comes in for unfair treatment at the hands of the world media. Sochi will prove that he probably has a point. In the eyes of the Western media, Russia is different, weirder somehow, stuck with that lunatic president of theirs, filled with corruption, vodka, and black bread. Expect all those tropes (and more!) to be deployed during the media extravaganza that’s barreling toward your eyeballs.
Oh, and don’t forget about the detaching doorknobs.
More from Foreign Policy
At Long Last, the Foreign Service Gets the Netflix Treatment
Keri Russell gets Drexel furniture but no Senate confirmation hearing.
How Macron Is Blocking EU Strategy on Russia and China
As a strategic consensus emerges in Europe, France is in the way.
What the Bush-Obama China Memos Reveal
Newly declassified documents contain important lessons for U.S. China policy.
Russia’s Boom Business Goes Bust
Moscow’s arms exports have fallen to levels not seen since the Soviet Union’s collapse.