CIA Employees Worry They’ll Be Shafted After Torture Report’s Release
Current and former CIA officials who participated in the agency’s brutal interrogations of terrorist suspects are worried that they’ll be "hung out to dry" by both their leaders and the White House when a blistering report accusing the agency of torture is publicly released in the coming days. The grim assessment comes from many who ...
Current and former CIA officials who participated in the agency's brutal interrogations of terrorist suspects are worried that they'll be "hung out to dry" by both their leaders and the White House when a blistering report accusing the agency of torture is publicly released in the coming days.
Current and former CIA officials who participated in the agency’s brutal interrogations of terrorist suspects are worried that they’ll be "hung out to dry" by both their leaders and the White House when a blistering report accusing the agency of torture is publicly released in the coming days.
The grim assessment comes from many who gathered at an auditorium at the CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia, on Thursday for what was meant to be a morale-boosting speech by the agency’s director, John Brennan. Instead of soothing frayed nerves, however, Brennan’s remarks left current and former CIA employees wondering if they might face disciplinary actions, public retribution, or even criminal charges.
One CIA employee asked the director whether individual employees could later find themselves caught in the political crosshairs the next time they’re asked to undertake a controversial mission. Brennan seemed "to dodge the question," and his presentation "went over like a lead balloon," said one former intelligence official who spoke to people who attended the town hall meeting. Brennan’s talk, which was described as an attempt to allay the anxieties of the workforce before an onslaught of criticism and press attention, "did not go well," a second former intelligence official said. Brennan spoke in an auditorium nicknamed "the Bubble," and his remarks were also carried on an internal CIA closed-circuit television system.
The meeting comes at an acutely sensitive time for the agency. The administration has finished its review of a nearly 600-page report by the Senate Intelligence Committee, which now has the final decision on when to release the document. That could come as early next week. Brennan and the CIA itself are also facing growing congressional fury over its admission this week that CIA spies improperly accessed Senate computers, a move that leading lawmakers describe as unconstitutional and an abuse of the agency’s powers. Some lawmakers have called for Brennan’s resignation.
President Obama said at the White House Friday that he had "full confidence" in Brennan, but he had harsh words for the CIA’s interrogation program and the operatives who took part in it. "We tortured some folks. We did some things that were contrary to our values," Obama said.
Obama acknowledged that after the 9/11 terrorist attacks there was "enormous pressure" on law enforcement and national security personnel to prevent another attack. Obama called many of those personnel "real patriots." Still, he said, "we did some things that were wrong."
The comments could reignite a simmering political debate about whether any CIA interrogators or senior officials should have faced criminal charges for their treatment of detainees, several of whom died in U.S. custody.
One of the first executive actions Obama took after winning election in 2008 was to prohibit the CIA from using so-called extraordinary interrogation techniques, which the Senate report describes as torture, according to individuals who have read it. The CIA had abandoned its use of those techniques years earlier. Obama ruled out the idea of pressing charges against any of the CIA personnel, a decision that infuriated many human rights advocates and members of his own party, and that appears not to have assuaged many agency employees.
The debate over the Bush-era interrogation programs has been dormant for years, but will likely flare up again when the report is made public. With the White House declassifying the report — which is a truncated version of a much larger 6,000-page document, which will likely never be released — lawmakers on the Senate Intelligence Committee will now review it for any redactions made by the White House and intelligence officials. That review will take at least a few days, according to sources familiar with the process. But at this point, the Senate committee is free to release the document, which concludes that the CIA didn’t glean any intelligence from torture that could prevent a terrorist attack, and that CIA officials misled Congress about the program.
The release has been partly overshadowed by the controversy over the CIA’s interference with the Senate’s investigation. Yesterday, the agency confirmed that its inspector general concluded that CIA employees inappropriately monitored the computers of Senate Intelligence Committee staffers who were reviewing millions of classified documents about the interrogation program. Obama said he agreed with the inspector general’s finding that some CIA employees acted inappropriately. Brennan apologized to the leaders of the committee, after earlier dismissing any suggestion that the CIA had spied on its congressional overseers.
Obama, at least for the moment, is standing by the CIA chief, long one of his closest national security advisers. Brennan worked on then-candidate Obama’s presidential campaign in 2008 and was initially his pick to run the CIA. But Brennan withdrew himself from consideration amid questions about his own involvement in the CIA’s torture program when he was a senior official at the agency during the George W. Bush administration.
Shane Harris was a senior staff writer at Foreign Policy from 2013-2014. Twitter: @shaneharris
More from Foreign Policy
America Is a Heartbeat Away From a War It Could Lose
Global war is neither a theoretical contingency nor the fever dream of hawks and militarists.
The West’s Incoherent Critique of Israel’s Gaza Strategy
The reality of fighting Hamas in Gaza makes this war terrible one way or another.
Biden Owns the Israel-Palestine Conflict Now
In tying Washington to Israel’s war in Gaza, the U.S. president now shares responsibility for the broader conflict’s fate.
Taiwan’s Room to Maneuver Shrinks as Biden and Xi Meet
As the latest crisis in the straits wraps up, Taipei is on the back foot.