They Can Take Our Freedom, But They Will Never Take Our Instagram
In the wake of China’s ban on the photo-sharing service, netizens are rushing to download software that lets them scale the Great Firewall.
When thousands of Hong Kong protesters clashed with police on Sunday, Sept. 28, many residents of the city immediately took to the photo-sharing platform Instagram. There, they uploaded images of police violence and demonstrations that shocked the world: smoky cascades of tear gas launched into swelling crowds, protesters wielding umbrellas to protect themselves from pepper spray, high school students struggling with riot police. These images never made it to mainland China, however, thanks to the speedy reaction of Beijing's censors.
When thousands of Hong Kong protesters clashed with police on Sunday, Sept. 28, many residents of the city immediately took to the photo-sharing platform Instagram. There, they uploaded images of police violence and demonstrations that shocked the world: smoky cascades of tear gas launched into swelling crowds, protesters wielding umbrellas to protect themselves from pepper spray, high school students struggling with riot police. These images never made it to mainland China, however, thanks to the speedy reaction of Beijing’s censors.
Read more from FP on Hong Kong
- Tea Leaf Nation:Hong Kong’s fractured media can’t agree on what the city’s pro-democracy protests mean.
- Tea Leaf Nation:Interview with Benny Tai: Hong Kong protests ‘Beyond What I Imagined.’
- Tea Leaf Nation:Meet people behind Hong Kong’s protests.
Or did they? The government’s decision to block Instagram on Sunday triggered a huge spike of interest in VPNs, or virtual private networks, on Chinese social media in the ensuing days. VPNs are a kind of software that allows users to scale the "Great Firewall" — the collective name given to the complex system of web censorship that keeps foreign social-networking sites like Facebook and Twitter inaccessible for most Chinese netizens — meaning that scenes from the "Umbrella Revolution" surely made it onto the mainland after all.
On Weibo, China’s huge microblogging platform, one Sept. 29 post offering instructions on how to download a VPN quickly went viral: It was retweeted more than 20,000 times in two hours. Censors later removed the post, but other VPN tutorials still remain accessible. One user who posted a tutorial commented that after using the recommended method, she was "so happy to be able to use Instagram again." With or without tutorials, it seems that many Chinese netizens were able to find what they were looking for — according to mobile app analytics platform App Annie which tracks Apple’s iOS App Store, as of Sept. 30, four of the top 50 most popular free apps in China were VPNs.* On another social media platform, a discussion forum on Instagram swiftly attracted users seeking access to the photo-sharing site. VPN tutorials posted to the forum received hundreds of comments; at one point, on Sept. 29, forum users were posting several new VPN tutorials every minute.
Social media users took note of this sudden spike in interest: On Sept. 29, the day after Instagram was blocked, one user posted a screen shot of App Annie’s top Chinese search terms, noting that "VPNs already monopolize" the list. Not everyone expects former Instagram users to find ways around the block, though. At least one enterprising shop on Taobao, an e-commerce platform, immediately began offering Instagram photo transfer services, at the price of 15 cents per 10 photos, to allow those without Instagram access to at least recover their photos.
Chinese authorities are unlikely to welcome this new surge of enthusiasm for firewall-evading software, given the great lengths mainland authorities go to in order to restrict the Internet activities of Chinese citizens. VPNs, which enable access to websites blocked within China by rerouting to a server located outside the mainland, remain legal in China, as long are they’ve been registered with the government — companies maintain that they’re necessary for business operations. But foreign VPNs are illegal, and the government occasionally cracks down on their use. The low number of Chinese users on such banned sites as Facebook and Twitter suggests that most Chinese residents rarely use VPNs to access blocked social media. The networks can also drastically slow connection speeds, and often charge a monthly fee for use.
The Instagram block, seemingly intended to prevent mainland Chinese from rallying to Hong Kong’s side and from witnessing the exercise of freedoms banned at home, may backfire by frustrating some of China’s otherwise politically apathetic social media users. Though some users took to Weibo to blame the Hong Kong protesters for getting Instagram blocked, others have expressed deep frustration with the obviously political censorship, repeatedly comparing China’s situation to that of North Korea. One user wrote, "China is more and more like North Korea," while another user commented, "Limiting social media feels like how in North Korea they can’t have cellphones."
Another user seemed at first to think that blocking Instagram would serve to catalyze China’s young social media users, commenting, "I was going to say that the ban on Instagram will make the younger generation realize what kind of society we’re living in right now and how horrible that is." But the user reconsidered: "With Instagram gone, there will be other apps to satisfy their need to socialize," wrote the user. "Most people will then stop using Instagram, and the people who do will find another way."
*Correction, Oct. 1, 2014: App Annie is an analytics site that tracks Apple’s iOS App Store. An earlier version of this article characterized App Annie as an app store. (Return to reading.)
Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian is a journalist covering China from Washington. She was previously an assistant editor and contributing reporter at Foreign Policy. Twitter: @BethanyAllenEbr
More from Foreign Policy
Saudi-Iranian Détente Is a Wake-Up Call for America
The peace plan is a big deal—and it’s no accident that China brokered it.
The U.S.-Israel Relationship No Longer Makes Sense
If Israel and its supporters want the country to continue receiving U.S. largesse, they will need to come up with a new narrative.
Putin Is Trapped in the Sunk-Cost Fallacy of War
Moscow is grasping for meaning in a meaningless invasion.
How China’s Saudi-Iran Deal Can Serve U.S. Interests
And why there’s less to Beijing’s diplomatic breakthrough than meets the eye.