Footloose and Falun Gong
An evening with the dance performance trying to bring down the Chinese Communist Party.
On a cool evening in late April, I watched a performance of Shen Yun, the two and a half hour variety show organized by the religious sect Falun Gong. Artistically, it was pleasant: The dancers are professionals, emotive and lithe. The emcees -- one American, one Chinese -- who introduce the acts and offer a bit of historical commentary, banter amicably if a bit awkwardly. Unsurprisingly for a performance held at Washington, D.C.’s John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, and at flagship theaters around the world, the show and the orchestra are technically superb.
On a cool evening in late April, I watched a performance of Shen Yun, the two and a half hour variety show organized by the religious sect Falun Gong. Artistically, it was pleasant: The dancers are professionals, emotive and lithe. The emcees — one American, one Chinese — who introduce the acts and offer a bit of historical commentary, banter amicably if a bit awkwardly. Unsurprisingly for a performance held at Washington, D.C.’s John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, and at flagship theaters around the world, the show and the orchestra are technically superb.
But Shen Yun, which ended its annual run at the Kennedy Center on April 26 and has performed in dozens of cities across the world since its founding in 2006, is not about the arts. It’s not about “reviving 5,000 years of civilization,” as the show’s ubiquitous fliers proclaim; nor is it a Chinese version of the wildly popular Canadian circus company Cirque du Soleil, as the older gentleman sitting next to me at the performance expected.
Rather, Shen Yun exists to transmit a message: that heavenly forces will destroy modern-day China, obliterating the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), which has ruled the country since 1949.
Falun Gong was founded in China in 1992 by qigong (energy cultivation) practitioner and former grain clerk Li Hongzhi. Emphasizing the three principles of truthfulness, compassion, and forbearance — values seen as lacking in modern China — the organization quickly grew in popularity. At its peak in the late 1990s, it had millions of practitioners across the country.
Practitioners perform breathing and movement exercises thought to improve health and extend one’s life. More serious members may subscribe to some of the organization’s religious beliefs, which borrow from the Buddhist notion of the cycles of rise, flourishing, decline, and death, says Benjamin Penny, author of the 2012 book The Religion of Falun Gong. “They’ve always had this notion that there was this physical end point coming, and that practitioners, or those that cultivate good to a certain level, will survive to the next cycle,” notes Penny, who’s also the deputy director of the Australian Centre on China in the World.
Practitioners of Falun Gong — also commonly known as Falun Dafa, which roughly means “Way of the Dharma Wheel” — stress that the organization was, and is, nonpolitical. Still, after an estimated 10,000 supporters massed for a silent protest outside the seat of the CCP government in the Chinese capital in April 1999, Beijing grew worried. Soon after, it launched a crackdown, one that continues to this day. Tens of thousands of practitioners have been detained, with an unknown number tortured and murdered. It remains illegal to practice Falun Gong — which Beijing has called an “evil cult” — in mainland China. (The laws are more permissive in Hong Kong, where authorities tolerate Falun Gong.)
Li moved to the United States in 1998. Although his precise whereabouts are a closely guarded secret, he is rumored to reside somewhere in the New York area, and he occasionally appears at Falun Gong events in New York City. An unknown but presumably very small number of people continue to practice Falun Gong inside mainland China. Outside the mainland, there are “maybe just tens of thousands” of practitioners, says Andrew Junker, an assistant professor at the University of Chicago who has studied Falun Gong. “They are very small and intensively organized,” he says.
Around 2000, Falun Gong practitioners decided to set up media organizations in the United States, including the broadcaster New Tang Dynasty Television (NTD TV) and the newspaper Epoch Times in part “to speak as the voice of Falun Gong,” as NTD TV’s then president, Zhong Lee, told the Wall Street Journal in a 2007 interview. The media outlets — which also cover a wide variety of general-interest news — seem to function as megaphones to amplify the persecution that Falun Gong practitioners have faced and continue to face in mainland China. But the aim is also to discredit the CCP.
Representatives from Falun Gong downplay the link between their organization, their media outlets, and Shen Yun. Dong Xiang, a practitioner and the executive director of the Falun Dafa Association of Washington, D.C., which put on the Kennedy Center show, emphasized in an interview that “Shen Yun is not a Falun Gong show, even though many of the artists practice Falun Gong.”
The show’s first act, “Following the Creator to Renew All Things,” casts doubt on that assertion; the first song, titled “A Song From the Ancestors,” disproves it. “Followers of a Great Way [Dafa] shall save us, even as they’re persecuted,” crooned the soprano. “The truth will be buried in lies.” Sung in Chinese, with an English translation broadcast on a massive screen, the song continues: “Followers of Dafa now spread truth to shatter delusion.” (Li is treated like a god among practitioners, “and that’s more or less how he represents himself,” says Junker.)
I polled roughly half a dozen people before the show, and only one of them knew of the Falun Gong connection — the others came for the dancing, singing, and acrobatics. At the beginning of the performance, excitement rippled through the three-quarters-full theater.
But when Falun Gong’s religious beliefs and politics started bleeding into the show, the applause quieted down. The audience wasn’t ecstatic about the Chinese dance story “The Power of Compassion,” which shows CCP policemen attacking Falun Gong sympathizers. Nor did they seem to appreciate the song “A Legend From My Town,” about the “holy ones” who will save us from the calamity of the “Red Beast.” That legend is now coming true, the song claims: As “the Red Regime falls, the Creator is delivering us back to heaven.”
The show ends with a song and dance about a CCP policeman who renounces his belief in the party. Falun Gong affiliates maintain websites — like this one on the Epoch Times — that urge CCP members “to leave the party” in order to maintain peace. Practitioners also organize “leave the party” phone banks — sometimes staffed by volunteers, sometimes playing automated messages — to call phone numbers in mainland China. “To leave the party, press 1,” said one message I received several years back in Beijing.
As the CCP policeman prays, a volcano spews lava over a Chinese city. “When all seems lost, and even the earth begins to erupt in fury, Lord Buddha appears, with divine beings trailing in his wake,” reads the liner notes. “And, with this heavenly scene, a new era begins.”
“When that day comes, when Heaven punishes the CCP, party members will be punished as well,” Dong, of the Falun Dafa Association of Washington, D.C., told me. “Because we know that this will come, we want to save the CCP members.” He likened it to the Jewish Passover story, where God tells the faithful to put lamb’s blood on their door.
Most of the audience didn’t seem to share the same apocalyptic enthusiasm for Falun Gong’s plans to save humanity. The Korean man seated to my right was sipping liberally from a bottle containing what appeared to be whiskey, and his sighs grew louder and louder as the night went on. Then they became snores. Roughly halfway through the performance, one of the emcees asked the audience, “How’s the show?” This awoke my seatmate.
“So-so!” the fairly intoxicated Korean man shouted gleefully, drawing a horrified stare from his companion.
The older couple on my left, who had expected an evening of kung fu and dancing, not political indoctrination, also seemed displeased. “I really liked the dance, the colors, and the movements,” said the woman, who declined to give her name, during the intermission. Maybe she was just being polite; they didn’t return to their seats for Act 2.
Photo credit: GEORGES GOBET/AFP/Getty Images
More from Foreign Policy
A New Multilateralism
How the United States can rejuvenate the global institutions it created.
America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want
Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.
The Endless Frustration of Chinese Diplomacy
Beijing’s representatives are always scared they could be the next to vanish.
The End of America’s Middle East
The region’s four major countries have all forfeited Washington’s trust.