In Afghanistan, a 17-Year Stalemate
America’s top general admits the war is at an impasse.
Another devastating suicide attack in Kabul on Tuesday and an independent report on the situation in Afghanistan serve to underscore what is now a growing consensus in Washington: that the United States is making no progress toward ending the 17-year-old war there.
More than 50 people were killed and at least 80 others injured when a suicide bomber blew himself up inside a wedding hall in the Afghan capital, according to reports. This comes as a blow to the Trump administration’s strategy in Afghanistan, as American military officials had made defending major urban centers such as Kabul from the Taliban a linchpin of the effort.
Just days before the bombing, America’s top general admitted the war is at an impasse. The Taliban is “not losing right now, I think that is fair to say,” Gen. Joseph Dunford, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said during the Halifax International Security Forum on Nov. 17.
“We used the term stalemate a year ago, and, relatively speaking, it has not changed much.”
Meanwhile, the U.S. Defense Department’s Office of Inspector General on Nov. 19 released a gloomy report on the fight in Afghanistan for the second quarter in a row, citing little progress toward reconciliation. Operations in the country drew particular scrutiny over the past month after a high-profile Taliban attack in the southern province of Kandahar killed an influential Afghan police general and the local intelligence chief, narrowly missing U.S. Gen. Scott Miller, the new commander of U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan.
In the midst of increasing violence, the U.S. envoy to Afghanistan, Zalmay Khalilzad, reportedly held three days of talks with the Taliban in Qatar over the weekend. At a news conference in Kabul on Sunday, Khalilzad struck a decidedly more optimistic tone than his military counterparts on peace efforts—though he did not mention the talks in Qatar.
“I think there is an opportunity for reconciliation and peace,” Khalilzad said. “The Taliban are saying they do not believe they can succeed militarily, that they would like to see the problems that remain, resolved by peaceful means, by political negotiations.”
But the peace talks have sputtered and stalled in the past. While military leaders over the summer lauded a brief cease-fire between the Afghan government and the Taliban over the Muslim holiday of Eid al-Fitr in June, the Taliban did not reply to Afghan President Ashraf Ghani’s offer to implement a second cease-fire. Instead, the Taliban focused on disrupting preparations for the October parliamentary elections, according to the Inspector General report.
James Dobbins, a former senior U.S. diplomat who served as special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan from 2013 to 2014, said there has been little progress in the past decade on bringing peace to Afghanistan. “Particularly for the last decade, we face a basic dilemma, which is that the best we can do is sustain the status quo—and that’s not a very satisfactory goal,” he said.
Meanwhile, the picture on the ground is increasingly dismal. For the past year diplomatic and military leaders have insisted that they are making headway toward the goals of the South Asia strategy, which in addition to defending population centers also includes airstrikes on Taliban narcotics labs and other revenue sources. The end goal is to pressure the Taliban into engaging in peace talks. In July, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said “the president’s strategy is indeed working,” and Gen. Joseph Votel, the commander of U.S. Central Command, later expressed cautious optimism. Speaking to reporters in August, outgoing commander of U.S. Forces-Afghanistan Gen. John Nicholson also said he believed the strategy is working.
But the numbers suggest otherwise. In addition to the most recent Taliban attacks, the branch of the Islamic State militant group in Afghanistan, known as Islamic State Khorasan, continued to mount deadly assaults in its stronghold in Nangarhar province and in Kabul, according to the latest Inspector General report, which covered the period between July 1 and Sept. 30. The number of suicide attacks increased by 38 percent between May and August compared to the same period last year, although there was a slight decrease in the number of overall security incidents. Meanwhile, there was an uptick in both civilian and Afghan military casualties. Sixty-five percent of Afghans live in areas under government control or influence, a figure that has not changed significantly in two years.
Humanitarian needs also grew more acute during the last quarter. The United Nations reported that drought put 3.5 million Afghans in need of urgent food assistance, and, between the drought and the ongoing conflict, the population of internationally displaced Afghans approached 500,000 this year, according to the Inspector General.
“This quarter was a difficult time for advancing reconciliation,” the report concludes.
In one small sign of progress, the elections did take place as scheduled on Oct. 20, despite a number of security and logistical challenges, according to the report. Dunford said the event was “largely successful and less violent, certainly, than people predicted,” noting that he believes the upcoming political transition will “be critical in putting pressure on the Taliban.”
The Inspector General is expected to provide a more comprehensive assessment of the parliamentary elections in the next quarterly report.
Echoing remarks by other senior U.S. leaders such as Secretary of Defense James Mattis, Dunford emphasized military pressure alone cannot bring peace in Afghanistan. The goal is to pressure the Taliban to the negotiating table.
“Success in Afghanistan is an Afghan-owned, Afghan-led reconciliation process,” he said. “That requires us to have political pressure, social pressure, and military pressure. In the military dimension, our task is to make sure the Taliban realize that they cannot win on the battlefield.”
Dobbins, the former U.S. diplomat, said the United States should try to clinch a peace deal with the Taliban, but he is skeptical the efforts will bear fruit. “It’s a good idea to try. It’s a bad idea to count on it.”
Lara Seligman is a staff writer at Foreign Policy. Twitter: @laraseligman
Robbie Gramer is a diplomacy and national security reporter at Foreign Policy. Twitter: @RobbieGramer