King Charles III Faces a Reckoning on Empire in Africa
Will a monarch known for voicing his personal views apologize for Britain’s crimes in Africa?
Welcome to Foreign Policy’s Africa Brief.
Welcome to Foreign Policy’s Africa Brief.
The highlights this week: South African President Cyril Ramaphosa heads to the White House, William Ruto is sworn in as president of Kenya, and Senegal makes strides toward parliamentary gender parity.
If you would like to receive Africa Brief in your inbox every Wednesday, please sign up here.
What King Charles III Means for Africa
King Charles III was officially proclaimed Britain’s new monarch last Saturday in a ceremony laden with ancient pomp as many in former British colonies and elsewhere noted that the late Queen Elizabeth II had never spoken out or apologized for crimes committed under the British Empire.
Unlike Elizabeth, Charles has not always toed the line of neutrality in British politics. His “black spider” handwritten notes to government ministers from 2004 onward drew accusations that he would be a “meddling” monarch. In the documents, Charles lobbied on issues including expanding what is taught in English and history courses, supplying more equipment for troops in Iraq, and the plight of the Patagonian toothfish.
In contrast to his mother, Charles found it hard not to let slip comments that revealed his personal opinions. In June, Charles represented the queen at the Commonwealth summit in Rwanda’s capital of Kigali. Two weeks prior to his visit, the Times of London reported that he had called the British government’s plan to send asylum-seekers to Rwanda “appalling.” His alleged comments drew furor from British politicians because under the country’s modern constitution the monarch, as head of state, is ceremonial and royals must be impartial on state affairs.
Charles’s involvement in proceedings also marked the first time the Commonwealth had publicly acknowledged the legacy of slavery or, as he put it, “the roots of our contemporary association.” (The Commonwealth’s 56 member states consist of former British colonies, but others such as Rwanda have since opted to join.) “I cannot describe the depths of my personal sorrow at the suffering of so many, as I continue to deepen my own understanding of slavery’s enduring impact,” Charles said.
“If we are to forge a common future that benefits all our citizens, we too must find new ways to acknowledge our past. Quite simply, this is a conversation whose time has come,” he added. It was not the first time that Charles had remarked on Britain’s imperial past. In 2018, when visiting Ghana, he said the country’s role in the trans-Atlantic slave trade was an “atrocity.”
Making that statement in Ghana—the first African country (excluding North Africa) to gain its independence from colonial rule—is laden with symbolism. It was at the Fifth Pan-African Congress, held in England in 1945, that delegates such as Jomo Kenyatta, who would become Kenya’s first president, and Kwame Nkrumah, later Ghana’s first president, set the era of decolonization in motion, declaring that “if the Western world is still determined to rule mankind by force, then Africans, as a last resort, may have to appeal to force in the effort to achieve Freedom. … We are determined to be Free.”
Of course, the most talked-about point of Ghana’s history among British politicians is the queen’s iconic dance with Nkrumah, during a post-independence state visit in 1961, when posters advising “No blacks, no dogs, no Irish” were still being posted on doors in her own country.
What’s often not mentioned is that Britain banned Ghanaian pro-independence political newspapers and imprisoned their editors. Kofi Baako, the editor in chief of the Cape Coast Daily Mail and later Ghana’s first defense minister, was imprisoned for sedition following the publication of his article “We Call for Freedom.” Nkrumah himself was given a three-year sentence in 1950 for leading nonviolent protests in Accra against British rule. He was imprisoned for a year in Fort James, Britain’s former trading post for enslaved people. Under Nkrumah’s leadership, Ghanaians embarked on a series of strikes, riots, and boycotts against British goods, leading to independence from Britain in 1957.
Today, Britain’s monarch is no longer the head of state in any of its 14 former African territories—a result of independence campaigns by Africans that were violently resisted by the British government during Elizabeth’s reign. In crushing the anti-colonial Mau Mau movement, which began just months after Elizabeth ascended the throne, at least 11,000 Mau Mau were killed, including more than 1,000 who were hanged by British authorities between 1952 and 1960.
The Kenya Human Rights Commission has estimated that 90,000 Kenyans were executed, tortured, or maimed and 160,000 detained. In 2013, it led to a 19.9 million pound ($31 million in 2013 dollars) payout shared among 5,000 Kenyan torture victims who sued the U.K. government.
Although African countries leaving the Commonwealth is unlikely, the bloc is the enduring legacy of international monetary systems designed to keep African countries dependent on Britain, as Kampala-based political analyst Nicholas Sengoba wrote in Uganda’s Daily Monitor newspaper. While African leaders mourned the queen’s passing, on social media writers from across Africa were less enthusiastic to adopt the sanitized versions of history promoted by the British government about a peaceful transition of power. As Nesrine Malik wrote in the Guardian, “The sun didn’t set on the empire: occupation was ejected, often in bloody wars. … The Queen is gone, and with her should go our imagined nation.”
Some comments touched nerves. Twitter removed a post by Uju Anya, a Nigeria-born professor at Carnegie Mellon University, in which she wished the queen “excruciating” pain for overseeing a “thieving raping genocidal empire.” The tweet faced criticism from her university, the British public, and Jeff Bezos—the billionaire founder of Amazon. BBC News Africa had to post a note on its social media platform asking audiences to “be respectful” following backlash against its tweet celebrating the queen’s long-standing relationship with Africa.
The British monarchy still benefits from its colonial wealth. Several treasures violently plundered from East and West African countries are part of the queen’s royal collection, which she refused to return and Charles has inherited. Inevitably, the clamor for their return will multiply. In South Africa, there are fresh debates about the Cullinan diamonds, which sat in the queen’s crown and scepter. The Congress of Traditional Leaders of South Africa confessed to “mixed feelings” even as it expressed its condolences.
Charles has indicated a need to modernize the monarchy. In carving out his own legacy, Charles may view the Commonwealth as a potential avenue to promote his climate activism, urban planning, and ideas around young people’s education. Programs under his charity The Prince’s Trust, which have helped a million vulnerable young people in Britain, now stretch to Ghana, Rwanda, Kenya, and the United States.
In his first speech as king, he pledged to no longer voice his political views and to “uphold the constitutional principles,” addressing some of the criticism against him. In a 2018 BBC interview, when asked whether his speaking out on issues would continue as king, he said, “No, it won’t. I’m not that stupid.” Still, some have questioned Charles’s ability to transition into the stoic objectivity that his mother maintained.
But Charles’s lower popularity and accusations of racism within the royal family after claims made by Meghan, the Duchess of Sussex, mean dissenting conversations about the monarchy and empire will grow in Africa. While Charles has referenced the debate as a fundamental issue, he has stopped short of a formal apology for Britain’s colonial past.
As Johannesburg-based political commentator Tafi Mhaka put it, Charles cannot simply get away with “woke” point-scoring by offering “meaningless expressions” of regret. He will inevitably have to address questions on the monarchy’s wealth as a result of colonization and on reparations, which have been demanded by Kenyans and Ghanaian President Nana Akufo-Addo. Charles will certainly be careful from now on about airing his personal views—but paradoxically a more outspoken king could improve the monarchy’s reputation across Africa.
The Week Ahead
Wednesday, Sept. 14: Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi meets with the emir of Qatar, Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani.
Wednesday, Sept. 14, to Thursday, Sept. 15: U.S. climate envoy John Kerry visits Senegal ahead of the 27th U.N. Climate Change Conference, or COP27.
Thursday, Sept. 15: The U.N. Security Council discusses its mission in South Sudan.
Friday, Sept. 16: U.S. President Joe Biden meets South African President Cyril Ramaphosa at the White House.
What We’re Watching
Biden-Ramaphosa meeting. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa and U.S. President Joe Biden will meet on Friday as the United States attempts to woo African nations away from a position of neutrality on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. As part of a new Africa policy, Washington has promised to better engage “African partners on global priorities.”
Biden and Ramaphosa are expected to focus their talks on trade and investment, infrastructure, climate and energy, public health, and South Africa’s leading role on the continent. The country is seen as influencing several African countries’ nonaligned position on Russia’s war. South Africa has abstained on U.N. votes to condemn Russia and instead has called for a mediated peace process.
Ramaphosa is likely to raise objections to a draft U.S. bill that would sanction African entities that do business with Russian individuals and companies that are sanctioned by the United States. For example, a joint venture with sanctioned Russian oligarch Viktor Vekselberg on Manganese mining has provided the ruling African National Congress (ANC) with dividends. Vekselberg holds a share in the South Africa-based United Manganese of Kalahari (UMK). The ANC’s investment front, Chancellor House, earned a reported 528 million South African rands (about $30 million) in 2020 from its indirect 22 percent share of UMK, according to the South African investigative platform amaBhungane.
During U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s visit to the country last month, his South African counterpart, Naledi Pandor, accused the United States and other Western countries of a bullying approach over the Russia-Ukraine war. “In some of our interactions with some of our partners in Europe and elsewhere, there has been a sense of patronizing bullying to say, ‘You choose this, or else,’” Pandor said. “Our trade with Russia is less than $4 billion annually compared to $20 billion with respect to the U.S., so this fear that we exist under some push is a totally unfounded belief,” Pandor added.
Egypt obstructs environmental groups. Human Rights Watch is the latest watchdog to accuse the Egyptian government of severely curtailing the freedom of civil society groups. Egypt will host the COP27 summit on climate change in November, but the group says the Egyptian government has imposed restrictions on environmental organizations in the country that severely limit their ability to carry out their work and has forced some activists into exile and others to steer clear of important work.
Human Rights Watch interviewed 13 activists, academics, scientists, and journalists working on environmental issues; they described harassment and intimidation tactics, including arrests and difficulties traveling.
Ruto sworn in. Around 60,000 people watched William Ruto’s inauguration on Tuesday as Kenya’s fifth president following his win in the Aug. 9 election. Last week, the Kenyan Supreme Court dismissed several petitions filed by losing opposition candidate Raila Odinga and his supporters that had challenged the election results. Outgoing President Uhuru Kenyatta, who had backed Odinga in the election, only congratulated Ruto a day before his inauguration.
This Week in Culture
Senegal now has the highest percentage of female parliamentarians in West Africa. On Monday, the largest proportion of women ever to be elected in the country took up their positions, following July’s elections. Out of the 165 parliamentary seats, 73 are held by women, representing more than 44 percent.
This is in contrast to Africa’s biggest economy, Nigeria, where women hold just 4 percent of parliamentary seats. In Senegal’s neighbor Gambia, only three women were elected to the National Assembly in its April election, with 53 seats up for grabs, despite representing 51 percent of the population.
In 2010, Senegal introduced a law that mandated “absolute gender parity” in all elected representation, national or local. At the time, women made up 52 percent of Senegal’s population but held just 23 percent of National Assembly seats.
Having nearly doubled the number of women in office, Senegal still ranks fourth in Africa after Rwanda, South Africa, and Namibia. It ranks 18th in the world, ahead of France, the United Kingdom, and the United States, according to data from the Inter-Parliamentary Union.
Female lawmakers hope greater gender parity will bring the country closer to reforming laws that harm women. Rape in Senegal was only criminalized in 2020, and one-quarter of the country’s female prison population is jailed for abortion-related crimes.
Chart of the Week
Women’s rates of participation in politics in Nigeria are still very low. Bills that aim to increase the number of women holding parliamentary positions in the country generally fail to progress or are voted down.
What We’re Reading
Reproductive rights. In African Arguments, Stephanie Musho argues that Kenya’s new parliament should enact reforms that break away from increasingly regressive U.S. policies on sexual and reproductive rights. The United States provides around 95 percent of Kenya’s sexual and reproductive health program funding and has a disproportionate influence over Nairobi’s policies. “The outgoing administration of Uhuru Kenyatta has opposed the delivery of sex education and contraception,” she writes.
Nigerian start-up in court. In Rest of World, Abubakar Idris reports on the Kenyan investigation into alleged fraudulent transactions made by Africa’s most valuable start-up, the Lagos-based Flutterwave.
Nosmot Gbadamosi is a multimedia journalist and the writer of Foreign Policy’s weekly Africa Brief. She has reported on human rights, the environment, and sustainable development from across the African continent. Twitter: @nosmotg
More from Foreign Policy
No, the World Is Not Multipolar
The idea of emerging power centers is popular but wrong—and could lead to serious policy mistakes.
America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want
Embedded with U.S. forces in the Pacific, I saw the dilemmas of deterrence firsthand.
America Can’t Stop China’s Rise
And it should stop trying.
The Morality of Ukraine’s War Is Very Murky
The ethical calculations are less clear than you might think.